Categories
Search


Advanced Search
 »  Home  »  Diamond Grading  »  GIA Excellent Cut Grade: Case Study  »  Ideal-Scope and AGS ASET scope results
GIA Excellent Cut Grade: Case Study
by Garry Holloway | Published  14/03/2006 | Diamond Grading
Ideal-Scope and AGS ASET scope results
Fig 3. shows Ideal-scope (top) and AGS ASET images for the same three diamonds from Table 1: shallow, ideal and deep.

Figure 3. Ideal-scope (top) and AGS ASET (bottom) images of the diamonds from Table 1

The shallow VG stone (A) shows too many dark zones in the ideal-scope and too much blue through ASET. The 'ideal' stone (B) has excellent Ideal-scope and ASET images, deserving of its Excellent cut grade. The deep GIA Excellent stone (C) has a lot of leakage just inside the table, and the dark or blue star pattern is weak in Ideal-scope and ASET images respectively. This stone has a very good DiamCalc contrast score (1.01), but because the stone is large enough for the leakage zone (contributing to the stones contrast score) to be visually seen as a circular dark zone, I believe the contrast result is misleading.

 

Article Series
Article Options
Popular Articles
  1. A review of the “foundation” of GIA’s new cut grade system
  2. USA Adventures June 2005
  3. The Diamond Industry in 2005
  4. AGS' new cut-grading of princesses: a first experience
  5. Why are there several dealers offering the exact same stone?
Popular Authors
  1. Garry Holloway
  2. Paul Slegers
  3. Neil Beaty
  4. David Atlas
  5. John Pollard